Timothy O'Toole's Pub Chicago - Chicago, Illinois

David P.

We were in the mood for some fish and chips while watching the Texas Rangers game in Chicago. We had to show our IDs before entering the pub, which is no big deal. The pub has plenty of TVs showing all sorts of sporting events. The wife ordered a cocktail and we had the spinach artichoke dip for an appetizer. Both the dip and the chips needed more salt. For dinner, the wife ordered chicken mac and cheese, and I had the fish and chips. The wife enjoyed her mac and cheese, but I've had better fish and chips. I am not saying it was bad at all, just that I've had better at other places. The service was hit and miss. The waiter was quick with water and soda and the food came out quickly, but we had to get the waiter's attention to get refills on the water and soda multiple times. We enjoyed watching the game as we ate and the crowd was lively.

Nicole E.

Amazing spot for delicious late-night food and drinks! Our server, Greta, went above and beyond to take care of our (admittedly high-maintenance) group with patience and a smile. The entire staff was incredibly attentive to allergy concerns—so much so that the chef personally came out to walk us through the menu and ensure everything was safe.

We started with two appetizers, planning to order mains afterward, but they were so generous and satisfying that I ended up skipping my entree and taking dessert to go. I couldn’t resist the pretzel bread pudding—and I’m so glad I didn’t. It was absolutely delicious!

Steven B.

We ate here during a recent trip to Chicago and it was a nice establishment. We ordered the Irish fries and a couple of burgers. The service was average, our server was a little slow and only came to our table twice in the hour we were there. We had to ask for water refills a couple of times and it wasn't that busy inside as we got an early dinner. Lots of TVs for watching the games. As a side note, we had a stroller with us and had to carry it down the stairs (not a big deal for us, as we are used to it), not sure if they had an elevator or another way down, just a heads up.

Mark T.

Not a big fan of leaving reviews but this one deserves it hands down. I live in Vegas and work in Chicago, normally it’s hard to compare experiences from Vegas to other cities but this place is very friendly, great service and amazing staff. Our bar tender Kaitlin is amazing I told her to surprise me and my colleague and ever since then it’s been amazing. She surprises us with new mix every drink. This place 10/10

Irfan S.

Love the ambiance & food of this pub. Never been disappointed. Great friendly service and welcoming atmosphere. Our go to place for the 4th meals or even light snacks.

Highly recommend this to Y'all.

Stephanie J.

Only went for a drink and the selection was great for holiday cocktails. Chocolate orange old fashion was a tall pour and well made. Only tried the truffle fries so can’t comment on food but bar service was good with TVs playing sports and acoustic wasn’t bad. Perfect after walking a bit in Chicago.

Paul P.

Now Timothy O'Toole's is a proper sports bar in the Streeterville neighborhood in Chicago. They have plenty of TVs around the central bar and along the outer walls. The beer selection is large. We also had the Reuben egg rolls, which are one of the best things we've eaten this entire trip. Prices are in line with most bars in the area. Staff is friendly.

Jawahn W.

Update- we came back 2 days later. Have to give shouts out to Lisa who was working the bar alone and a group of 50 ppl showed up. When I say she did "her thang" managing with a smile....she was awesome. I love, love, love how managers Jason and Rashed stepped in to help. When we come back to the city, this will be a favorite....and I'm telling my friends that live here to support!
------------------------

We stumbled upon this bar because the one we were looking for had not opened yet. So glad we did. We sat at the bar (Chiefs at Browns was playing). HUGE seating atmosphere. Good service. Ruben eggrolls 👍🏽 but that turkey melt 👍🏽👍🏽🙌🏿! I have never had a margarita on tap....that Tres Agave is asombrosa [amazing]!!!!